Which arcade controls should I get?

On Windows or Switch, get the 8bitdo Arcade Stick. Other consoles have the Mayflashes—except the PlayStation 5, where you'll pay dearly for a Hori Alpha or Victrix Pro; the Hori Mini is inexpensive but you may well dislike just how mini it is. Live the dream, build your own.

Just Buy The Toaster. Concise product recommendations.